Pat !


Here's two "Eagle" mockups and one "Badge" mockup.
The first eagle version is very similar to your original design. The eagle is in a similar pose, and this flag element is well-suited for the new design. The outside lettering is all caps, in a strong, solid font. The letters are an off-white, warmer, leaving room for the highlights when we go to the 3D effects. The "est. 1996" is slightly larger.
The second eagle version has a couple of changes; a different eagle, and a simple sky background in place of the black.
In comparing the two, there will be a difference when we get to the finishing stage. The second eagle's left wing can protrude over the outer ring, which would give an illusion that the bird is flying out from behind the ring. The first eagle is entirely contained within the ring. The second eagle's right wing, and the flag would cover part of "Police" if they came out over the ring on the right side.
Finally, the badge rework is the last image. The layers have been re-ordered and gold shades brought in, along with the blue center element. This file is ready to add the 3D effects.